
Some words just don’t have the same meaning that they used to. For instance, nowadays when I unthinkingly say to a person, “I’ll hook up with you later,” I then have to immediately follow it with, “I didn’t mean it THAT way!”
Today, hooking-up is defined as a sexual encounter without a relationship and no intention for
a commitment. This sexual behavior can include just kissing or touching, but increasingly the term “hooking up” refers to having oral sex and/or sexual intercourse. And it increasingly is a commonplace
event among adolescents.
Recently I discovered an article on this topic in the Journal of Evolutionary Psychology. The name of this journal conjures up images of mental health experts studying mating habits in the animal kingdom. Well, that’s exactly what it’s about.
Hooking-up can be likened to a type of mating behavior, and that’s why it’s examined in this article by Chris Reiber and Justin R. Garcia. In “Hooking Up: Gender Differences, Evolution, and Pluralistic Ignorance,” the researchers surveyed 507 male and female college students. Of these students, 80% reported that they had engaged in “hooking up” at least once during their college career.
The researchers state that it is not surprising that a lot of men engage in hook-up behavior. After all, male humans are more “sexually eager” than female humans, and their sexual activity has fewer ramifications for them. Further, speaking in strictly evolutionary terms, this trait helps males of any species achieve a higher rate of reproductive success, which in turn helps them to ensure the continuance of their own genes and the survival of their own species. In other words, for men, the more mates the better.
But it should be different for women. Generally speaking, females of any species are biologically predisposed to being choosy in selecting a mate. In evolutionary terms, being sexually active, particularly with a number of different mates, carries with it an increased risk of long-term consequences such as pregnancy and the responsibility of raising off-spring. Further, in a number of species, females have to consider additional factors such as acquiring security and resources for the care of those offspring. Therefore, at an evolutionary level, it seems perplexing that so many young women today readily engage in hooking-up behavior.
Of course, a big part of the reason for this divergence between evolutionary predisposition and actual actions in women can be summed up in one term: “birth control.” But there is another reason as well. It, too, can be summed up in one term: “oral sex.” Although oral sex with multiple partners poses a significant risk for getting a sexually transmitted disease, there is no risk of pregnancy and offspring.
Here are some of the survey results contained in the journal article:
35% students engaged in receiving oral sex
36% students engaged in performing oral sex
34% students engaged in sexual intercourse
19% students engaged in no touching, oral sex,
or intercourse
But as the researchers note, there is another aspect to hooking-up that should not be ignored – the psychological effects.
According to the journal article, when the researchers measured “comfort levels” with hooking-up, they found the following results:
Men reported higher comfort levels than women with all
sexual behaviors.
Men overestimated women’s level of comfort with hooking-up.
Women overestimated men’s level of comfort with hooking-up.
Men perceived higher comfort levels among their male
peers “than they, themselves, felt.”
Women perceived higher comfort levels among their female
peers “than they, themselves, felt.”
So, the bottom line is that despite the high percentage of students engaging in hooking-up, there actually are fairly low levels of comfort among them with this behavior. So why do they do it?
There are a couple of potential answers to this question. First and foremost, adolescents often engage in sexual behavior because of their urges and impulses fueled by their hormones. That’s pretty obvious. But there may be other, more subtle, reasons as well.
Students may be hooking up because they think it is a “perceived norm.” In other words, they are doing it because they believe they SHOULD be doing it. That’s a really problematic reason. The authors of the journal article note that there is a rise in the number of women seeking help after “traumatic and regretful sexual hook-up experiences…” Many young women simply are not able to dissociate their emotions from the casual sexual encounters in this hook-up culture, or feel they have violated their religious or moral codes, and thus confusion and depression follow.
And interestingly, while the majority of the participants in this study disclosed that they had no expectations that a hook-up would turn into a traditional romantic relationship, more than 50% of the male and female students in the survey indicated that a strong factor in motivating them to engage in a hook-up was the desire to begin a traditional romantic relationship. And so, they were placing the sex first, and the courtship later. Interesting….
As always, I encourage you to talk to your daughter about this phenomenon. Speak openly about this issue and about your views on this matter. By doing so, you will help your daughter to make the best choices for her. And perhaps – just perhaps -- she will see the wisdom (and fun) of getting to know someone well before taking on the challenges of a more intimate, physical relationship.